I needed to disable self sign-ups because I’ve been getting too many spam-type accounts. Thanks.
Zinc therapy for night blindness in cystic fibrosis
Quote from tim on September 11, 2020, 7:31 amZinc therapy for night blindness in cystic fibrosis
Zinc is absorbed by enterocytes in the proximal small intestine, and zinc deficiency has been associated with malabsorption syndromes such as CF [4]. In CF, unabsorbed fat specifically interferes with the re-absorption of endogenous zinc [5], and this, together with prior small bowel resection, may have contributed to the zinc deficiency in this case. Furthermore, iron supplementation has been shown to inhibit zinc absorption in the human small intestine [6].
The knowledge of zinc metabolism in the eye is fragmentary. Much of the evidence for its role in retinal function comes from interaction studies with other nutrients, a few naturally occurring diseases and in vitro studies [4]. It is known that zinc interacts with taurine and vitamin A in the retina, modifies plasma membranes in the photoreceptors, regulates the light-rhodopsin reaction within the photoreceptor, modulates synaptic transmission and serves as an anti-oxidant in both the retinal pigment epithelium and retina [4]. Although zinc deficiency was previously thought to impair retinol dehydrogenase activity, it is now known that this enzyme is zinc independent [7]. However, numerous other enzymes important in the visual cycle may be zinc dependent. Zinc deficiency can depress the hepatic synthesis of retinol-binding protein (RBP) and lead to lower concentrations of RBP in the plasma, which is required for mobilization of retinol from the liver [8]. In addition, there may be a specific role of zinc in the conversion of β-carotene to retinol via the enzyme 15-15 dioxygenase [9].
Zinc deficiency has been implicated in rod dysfunction and a patient with liver cirrhosis and night blindness was reported to show an improvement in rod ERG's after treatment with oral cholagogues, and this was attributed to recovery of deficient serum zinc levels and liver function [10]. Morrison et al. demonstrated a rapid recovery in cirrhotic patients with impaired dark adaptation and low serum zinc levels on zinc supplementation alone [11]. There appears to be an interaction between zinc and vitamin A in patients suffering from various pathological conditions that severely compromise hepatic function, such as alcoholic cirrhosis, CF and idiopathic haemochromatosis [8]. In humans, cross-sectional studies have more often than not shown a weak linkage between vitamin A and zinc status [8]. However randomized trials have failed to show a consistent effect of zinc supplementation on vitamin A status [8]. Circulating zinc and vitamin A levels appear unrelated in well-nourished states, but tend to co-vary in marginally nourished individuals, with co-existing zinc and vitamin A deficiencies [8]. Intestinal vitamin A malabsorption may be due to specific effects of zinc deficiency beyond any generalized effects of malnutrition. Thus zinc deficiency may result in a secondary vitamin A deficiency that is reflected in low serum vitamin A concentrations [7]. Conversely, severe vitamin A deficiency may reduce absorption and lymphatic transport of zinc by altering the synthesis of zinc-dependent binding protein [8].
Low serum vitamin A levels occur frequently in clinically stable, retinol-supplemented CF patients [12]. However due to the absence of a statistical correlation between hepatic and plasma levels of retinol in CF, serum retinol does not reflect vitamin A status [12]. A defective mobilization of vitamin A from liver storage tissues has been proposed as the reason for this, which indeed may be due to a co-existing zinc deficiency. Thus even in the presence of adequate hepatic vitamin A reserves, night blindness may occur when zinc deficiency exists [7]. However, to date, studies regarding zinc-related vitamin A deficiency in CF have been inconclusive [8].
A proportion of CF patients on oral vitamin A supplementation have abnormal dark adaptation and conjunctival xerosis due to vitamin A deficiency [13]. Some patients with abnormal dark adaptation do not respond to increasing their vitamin A intake until zinc supplements are administered [13]. In CF patients with vitamin A deficiency, therapy can be commenced with intramuscular water soluble vitamin A 30 000 IU [14]. However in this case it was difficult to source locally. Furthermore, high-dose vitamin A supplementation should be given with caution due to its potential for hepatotoxicity and risk of intracranial hypertension [12]. It was previously thought that among zinc deficient subjects, zinc on its own may not resolve night blindness or poor dark adaptation, but acts only to potentiate vitamin A in preventing night blindness [7]. This is the first report of a supplemented CF patient presenting with clinical vitamin A deficiency to be successfully treated with zinc supplementation alone.
Therefore in addition to retinol supplementation, normalising serum zinc levels may be important in maintaining the vitamin A status of CF patients. A routine enquiry as to whether patients were experiencing problems seeing at night would seem worthwhile. The European consensus on nutrition in patients with CF recommends up to 10 000 IU daily of fat soluble vitamin A, to maintain serum concentrations within the normal range. If serum concentrations are found to be low, despite supplementation to these levels, consideration should be given to patient compliance and zinc levels should be measured [15].
Zinc therapy for night blindness in cystic fibrosis
Zinc is absorbed by enterocytes in the proximal small intestine, and zinc deficiency has been associated with malabsorption syndromes such as CF [4]. In CF, unabsorbed fat specifically interferes with the re-absorption of endogenous zinc [5], and this, together with prior small bowel resection, may have contributed to the zinc deficiency in this case. Furthermore, iron supplementation has been shown to inhibit zinc absorption in the human small intestine [6].
The knowledge of zinc metabolism in the eye is fragmentary. Much of the evidence for its role in retinal function comes from interaction studies with other nutrients, a few naturally occurring diseases and in vitro studies [4]. It is known that zinc interacts with taurine and vitamin A in the retina, modifies plasma membranes in the photoreceptors, regulates the light-rhodopsin reaction within the photoreceptor, modulates synaptic transmission and serves as an anti-oxidant in both the retinal pigment epithelium and retina [4]. Although zinc deficiency was previously thought to impair retinol dehydrogenase activity, it is now known that this enzyme is zinc independent [7]. However, numerous other enzymes important in the visual cycle may be zinc dependent. Zinc deficiency can depress the hepatic synthesis of retinol-binding protein (RBP) and lead to lower concentrations of RBP in the plasma, which is required for mobilization of retinol from the liver [8]. In addition, there may be a specific role of zinc in the conversion of β-carotene to retinol via the enzyme 15-15 dioxygenase [9].
Zinc deficiency has been implicated in rod dysfunction and a patient with liver cirrhosis and night blindness was reported to show an improvement in rod ERG's after treatment with oral cholagogues, and this was attributed to recovery of deficient serum zinc levels and liver function [10]. Morrison et al. demonstrated a rapid recovery in cirrhotic patients with impaired dark adaptation and low serum zinc levels on zinc supplementation alone [11]. There appears to be an interaction between zinc and vitamin A in patients suffering from various pathological conditions that severely compromise hepatic function, such as alcoholic cirrhosis, CF and idiopathic haemochromatosis [8]. In humans, cross-sectional studies have more often than not shown a weak linkage between vitamin A and zinc status [8]. However randomized trials have failed to show a consistent effect of zinc supplementation on vitamin A status [8]. Circulating zinc and vitamin A levels appear unrelated in well-nourished states, but tend to co-vary in marginally nourished individuals, with co-existing zinc and vitamin A deficiencies [8]. Intestinal vitamin A malabsorption may be due to specific effects of zinc deficiency beyond any generalized effects of malnutrition. Thus zinc deficiency may result in a secondary vitamin A deficiency that is reflected in low serum vitamin A concentrations [7]. Conversely, severe vitamin A deficiency may reduce absorption and lymphatic transport of zinc by altering the synthesis of zinc-dependent binding protein [8].
Low serum vitamin A levels occur frequently in clinically stable, retinol-supplemented CF patients [12]. However due to the absence of a statistical correlation between hepatic and plasma levels of retinol in CF, serum retinol does not reflect vitamin A status [12]. A defective mobilization of vitamin A from liver storage tissues has been proposed as the reason for this, which indeed may be due to a co-existing zinc deficiency. Thus even in the presence of adequate hepatic vitamin A reserves, night blindness may occur when zinc deficiency exists [7]. However, to date, studies regarding zinc-related vitamin A deficiency in CF have been inconclusive [8].
A proportion of CF patients on oral vitamin A supplementation have abnormal dark adaptation and conjunctival xerosis due to vitamin A deficiency [13]. Some patients with abnormal dark adaptation do not respond to increasing their vitamin A intake until zinc supplements are administered [13]. In CF patients with vitamin A deficiency, therapy can be commenced with intramuscular water soluble vitamin A 30 000 IU [14]. However in this case it was difficult to source locally. Furthermore, high-dose vitamin A supplementation should be given with caution due to its potential for hepatotoxicity and risk of intracranial hypertension [12]. It was previously thought that among zinc deficient subjects, zinc on its own may not resolve night blindness or poor dark adaptation, but acts only to potentiate vitamin A in preventing night blindness [7]. This is the first report of a supplemented CF patient presenting with clinical vitamin A deficiency to be successfully treated with zinc supplementation alone.
Therefore in addition to retinol supplementation, normalising serum zinc levels may be important in maintaining the vitamin A status of CF patients. A routine enquiry as to whether patients were experiencing problems seeing at night would seem worthwhile. The European consensus on nutrition in patients with CF recommends up to 10 000 IU daily of fat soluble vitamin A, to maintain serum concentrations within the normal range. If serum concentrations are found to be low, despite supplementation to these levels, consideration should be given to patient compliance and zinc levels should be measured [15].
Quote from ggenereux on September 11, 2020, 8:25 amHi @tim-2,
Thanks again for finding that and sharing it.
There are other papers documenting that CF patients have very low levels of the RBPs.
Here's an example: https://www.nature.com/articles/pr1971188
Therefore, it's quite likely that zinc does not potentiate vitamin A.
Rather, it's that zinc is helping build more RBPs and other enzymes needed to protect from vA toxicity.
Hi @tim-2,
Thanks again for finding that and sharing it.
There are other papers documenting that CF patients have very low levels of the RBPs.
Here's an example: https://www.nature.com/articles/pr1971188
Therefore, it's quite likely that zinc does not potentiate vitamin A.
Rather, it's that zinc is helping build more RBPs and other enzymes needed to protect from vA toxicity.
Quote from pano200 on September 11, 2020, 8:39 amnot related to zinc, but i did find a paper that did AM of biopsy serum VA/serum RBP, and a liver retinyl palmitate: https://journals.lww.com/jpgn/Fulltext/1997/03000/Vitamin_A_Concentration_in_the_Liver_Decreases.6.aspx
it does seem CF patients have low RBP
not related to zinc, but i did find a paper that did AM of biopsy serum VA/serum RBP, and a liver retinyl palmitate: https://journals.lww.com/jpgn/Fulltext/1997/03000/Vitamin_A_Concentration_in_the_Liver_Decreases.6.aspx
it does seem CF patients have low RBP
Quote from tim on September 12, 2020, 3:16 am@ggenereux2014
You're welcome. I have quite a different interpretation but that's ok!
My interpretation is that zinc (and other nutrients?) deficiency is often responsible for xeropthalmia due to impaired vA utilization. This explains why xeropthalmia is common in many countries despite vA being present in the diet and why vA supplementation in these countries often isn't as effective as expected.
You're welcome. I have quite a different interpretation but that's ok!
My interpretation is that zinc (and other nutrients?) deficiency is often responsible for xeropthalmia due to impaired vA utilization. This explains why xeropthalmia is common in many countries despite vA being present in the diet and why vA supplementation in these countries often isn't as effective as expected.
Quote from ggenereux on September 12, 2020, 7:01 amHi @tim-2,
Yes, I completely disagree.
If it were a combination deficiency of zinc and vitamin A then there should have been widespread xerophthalmia recorded in the Far East POW populations during WWII.
From the report I shared before:
The rice was polished and of poor quality, and vitamin B deficiency became rapidly a major problem.
So, without zinc nor vA for three years, it should have been the perfect double whammy scenario to cause xerophthalmia. Yet, the term xerophthalmia isn’t even mentioned in that report.
Did the early vA deficiency researchers just really prove a zinc deficiency then, and not that of vA after all?
Hi @tim-2,
Yes, I completely disagree.
If it were a combination deficiency of zinc and vitamin A then there should have been widespread xerophthalmia recorded in the Far East POW populations during WWII.
From the report I shared before:
The rice was polished and of poor quality, and vitamin B deficiency became rapidly a major problem.
So, without zinc nor vA for three years, it should have been the perfect double whammy scenario to cause xerophthalmia. Yet, the term xerophthalmia isn’t even mentioned in that report.
Did the early vA deficiency researchers just really prove a zinc deficiency then, and not that of vA after all?
Quote from tim on September 12, 2020, 8:27 am@ggenereux2014
Yeah I don't expect us coming to any agreement any time soon on this issue but at least we're in agreement about how problematic vA can be.
Consequences of captivity: health effects of far East imprisonment in World War II
Are you talking about this report? Night blindness is listed in Table 1 as a common problem.
White rice is not devoid of nutrition, in fact zinc deficiency is more likely from a diet based on whole grains due to phytate. The zinc present in white rice is more absorbable. I'm not saying they weren't zinc deficient but they were getting some zinc. It also says they got small amounts of vegetables and meat as well. They were also zinc replete until they got captured.
I think many older studies that show xeropthalmia in animals after a short period of time didn't cause it by fully depleting the vA stores in the liver (do any of these old studies analyse the liver of these animals for vA at the end of the experiment?), they caused other deficiencies that interfered with vA utilization in the eye. You mentioned an experiment giving dogs just sugar water, that one is a prime example of that.
A person consuming a diet that is very low in vA but otherwise sufficient in all other nutrients will take many years to exhibit symptoms of xeropthalmia. I've only read about children on restrictive diets that happened to be very low vA getting it after many years. For many of us that started the low vA diet with livers saturated with vA who knows how long it would take to get xeropthalmia?
Yeah I don't expect us coming to any agreement any time soon on this issue but at least we're in agreement about how problematic vA can be.
Consequences of captivity: health effects of far East imprisonment in World War II
Are you talking about this report? Night blindness is listed in Table 1 as a common problem.
White rice is not devoid of nutrition, in fact zinc deficiency is more likely from a diet based on whole grains due to phytate. The zinc present in white rice is more absorbable. I'm not saying they weren't zinc deficient but they were getting some zinc. It also says they got small amounts of vegetables and meat as well. They were also zinc replete until they got captured.
I think many older studies that show xeropthalmia in animals after a short period of time didn't cause it by fully depleting the vA stores in the liver (do any of these old studies analyse the liver of these animals for vA at the end of the experiment?), they caused other deficiencies that interfered with vA utilization in the eye. You mentioned an experiment giving dogs just sugar water, that one is a prime example of that.
A person consuming a diet that is very low in vA but otherwise sufficient in all other nutrients will take many years to exhibit symptoms of xeropthalmia. I've only read about children on restrictive diets that happened to be very low vA getting it after many years. For many of us that started the low vA diet with livers saturated with vA who knows how long it would take to get xeropthalmia?
Quote from ggenereux on September 13, 2020, 4:30 amHi @tim-2,
Yes, night blindness is stated in that report, but not xerophthalmia (lesions of the eye). And, night blindness is a documented symptom of a thiamine deficiency too.
RE: do any of these old studies analyse the liver of these animals for vA at the end of the experiment?
Actually, the comprehensive vA toxicity studies done in Norway in the late 1940’s did analyse the vA content of the liver post experiment, (as well as most other organs) and reported a lot of vA (and fat) accumulated in these organs. With that, massive swelling and inflammation of the eyes is almost always reported. If I remember correctly, in some of their experiments they used liver as a food source for the vA fed to their animals. So, their animals had lots of zinc + lots of vA and it still quickly resulted in xerophthalmia conditions, and very often a painful death.
Anyways, no-problem, we can continue to agree to disagree. It’s always good to have the counterargument here.
Hi @tim-2,
Yes, night blindness is stated in that report, but not xerophthalmia (lesions of the eye). And, night blindness is a documented symptom of a thiamine deficiency too.
RE: do any of these old studies analyse the liver of these animals for vA at the end of the experiment?
Actually, the comprehensive vA toxicity studies done in Norway in the late 1940’s did analyse the vA content of the liver post experiment, (as well as most other organs) and reported a lot of vA (and fat) accumulated in these organs. With that, massive swelling and inflammation of the eyes is almost always reported. If I remember correctly, in some of their experiments they used liver as a food source for the vA fed to their animals. So, their animals had lots of zinc + lots of vA and it still quickly resulted in xerophthalmia conditions, and very often a painful death.
Anyways, no-problem, we can continue to agree to disagree. It’s always good to have the counterargument here.