Discussion

I needed to disable self sign-ups because I’ve been getting too many spam-type accounts. Thanks.

Forum Navigation
Please to create posts and topics.

A common deterioration one year after starting a low-vitamin A diet?

PreviousPage 5 of 5
Quote from Janelle525 on January 9, 2026, 11:31 am

@jiri

I used to be a fan of high metabolic rate and higher calories....Ray Peat much? Until I nearly killed myself 'pushing metabolism'. And we know that Ray Peat on his higher metabolic rate diet didn't live any longer than most people nowadays. So why does it even matter then? Do I agree with a zero vitamin A diet and low calories? No, I do not. I do applaud his effort to prove his theory though. He's using his body as a science experiment. He should have gone blind at the level of vit A in his blood by now. I usually eat only 1500-1700 calories but I'm 5'2 124 lbs and mostly sedentary. 

I find that when I push vA in diet close to zero (10 mcg - 50 mcg), the next day or so, I feel awful. Bone pain, joint pain, malaise, nausea  … basically just feeling extremely unwell—I am still early in my lowered vA journey.

If I bump it up to 100 - 250 mcg (always only from food  … and that just means a more liberal diet without reverting to eggs or cheese or high vA veggies), I feel much better (but I am also probably not detoxing as fast).

@bruce what are the differences in your diet between when you do near-zero vA, vs. the low vA diet (100-250 mcg).

Is the caloric intake the same both ways? Are there certain foods you eat more or less of between the two diets?

I'm wondering if your low variant has more fiber, or perhaps other aspects, which are positively affecting your serum levels of retinol and/or retinoic acid. Also, if your near-zero diet has fewer calories, your body may be burning/mobilizing some of your fat stores, which could be putting more retinol/retinoic acid into your system.

Feeling nausea, bone pain, joint pain, etc. is probably due to (transiently) elevated serum retinol and/or retinoic acid. Beta-carotene by itself I don't think would acutely cause those symptoms is small quantities. Just my opinion.

Quote from Navid on June 28, 2026, 12:50 pm

@bruce what are the differences in your diet between when you do near-zero vA, vs. the low vA diet (100-250 mcg).

Is the caloric intake the same both ways? Are there certain foods you eat more or less of between the two diets?

I'm wondering if your low variant has more fiber, or perhaps other aspects, which are positively affecting your serum levels of retinol and/or retinoic acid. Also, if your near-zero diet has fewer calories, your body may be burning/mobilizing some of your fat stores, which could be putting more retinol/retinoic acid into your system.

Feeling nausea, bone pain, joint pain, etc. is probably due to (transiently) elevated serum retinol and/or retinoic acid. Beta-carotene by itself I don't think would acutely cause those symptoms is small quantities. Just my opinion.

From what I can see on cronometer, my near-zero diet has about the same calories, but include much more beans. I get around the same number of fiber calories, as I have always and continue to take psyllium.

Also, as a flexitarian, who leans more towards vegetarian food 90% of the time, those low-vA days were MOSTLY vegetables (beans, rice, a little meat, green peas, hummus, etc.). On other days where I am not aiming so low, I do include more animal protein. 

So feeling badly might either be the reduced animal protein or my body influencing a dump? Either way, the bad feeling always seems to happen the next day or the day after (or both). It's almost like my body is saying, "He only got 40 mcg of vA, let's release the Kraken!"

Yes, it is plausible that going very low in vitamin A may encourage the body to release more stores. But it could also be related to what you're eating. Animal protein might help the body produce retinol binding protein (RBP), which I think helps the body to safely bind the retinol that's floating around the body.

Bruce has reacted to this post.
Bruce
Quote from Navid on June 30, 2026, 7:59 am

Yes, it is plausible that going very low in vitamin A may encourage the body to release more stores. But it could also be related to what you're eating. Animal protein might help the body produce retinol binding protein (RBP), which I think helps the body to safely bind the retinol that's floating around the body.

I'm not a huge meat-eater, but I DO feel better when consuming more animal based protein. I prefer chicken or fish, but I don't really have aversions to beef or lamb at times. 

Navid has reacted to this post.
Navid
PreviousPage 5 of 5
Scroll to Top